Skip to content
Stove & Snow
Standards

Editorial policy

What we will publish, what we will not, how we correct mistakes, and why a site that sells nothing can afford to be blunt about products.

Last updated

Notebook, pencil and measuring tape on a wooden desk

Independence

We sell no products. That is worth stating first because it is not the norm in this category. When we surveyed the publishers ranking for the main sauna and cold plunge terms, four of ten were companies selling the products they ranked — one guide was written by the founder and CEO of the brand it placed first — and none disclosed that prominently.

We have no stock, no manufacturer relationships, no sponsorships and no paid placements. Our only revenue is affiliate commission, set out in full in the affiliate disclosure, and commission rate plays no part in how anything is ranked.

Sourcing standards

  1. 1Every specification cites its source. Manufacturer pages, manuals, published standards or the seller's own listing — with the date we checked it. There are currently 173 citations across the site.
  2. 2Every physiological claim links to a specific study. Not "studies show", not "a growing body of research" — a named, linked paper. If we cannot link one, the claim does not get made.
  3. 3We state whether evidence is observational or interventional, in the sentence rather than in a footnote, because that distinction does most of the work in interpreting a finding.
  4. 4Where a figure is not published, we say "Not published" rather than estimating it. A blank cell honestly labeled beats an invented number.
  5. 5Where a competitor's guide is referenced, we identify it as seller-published if it is.

What we will never publish

  • Fabricated reviews, testimonials, ratings or review counts. There are none anywhere on this site and there never will be.
  • Invented prices. We do not print prices at all, because we run no live price feed and a stale number shown as current is worse than none.
  • Invented ASINs or product links. Every product here was found in Amazon's own indexed listings, and every direct product link was confirmed against a live page during the build.
  • Testing claims. We do not test hardware and no page will ever imply we do — no claim to have handled, benched, measured or trialed any product covered here.
  • Credentials we do not hold. No certifications, no claimed review board, no clinical sign-off.
  • Health overreach. No "detoxifies", no "cures", no calorie-burn figures, no claim that any product treats any condition.
  • Tenure claims. No assertions of long service, seniority, or accumulated time in the category.

Corrections

If we get something wrong, we fix it, date the change, and describe what changed. We do not quietly amend a page and leave the date untouched — that is how a reader loses the ability to tell whether they read the current version.

Corrections get read before anything else that arrives through the contact form. If you have found a misread spec, a dead link, a figure that has moved, or a source that does not say what we say it says, tell us. You do not need to be polite about it.

Refresh cadence

How often things are re-checked
CadenceWhat happens
QuarterlyEvery roundup re-verified against live manufacturer specifications
QuarterlyEvery product link re-checked to confirm it still resolves to a live listing
On any spec changePage updated, change dated, noted in the Sources section
On any error foundCorrected, dated and described
AnnuallyEvery cited study re-checked to confirm it still supports the claim made

We do not restamp unchanged pages. A page's `lastmod` reflects a real edit, because a sitemap claiming everything changed every day is a sitemap search engines learn to ignore.

Who writes this

Sawyer V. writes everything here — an enthusiast who reads the manuals, compiles the specs and does the arithmetic. No credentials, no test lab, and no claim to either. Every editorial page carries that byline because a human byline over an anonymous organization is a coherence failure, and because someone should be accountable for what is on a page.

How rankings are decided

The criteria differ by category and are set out in full on the methodology page, along with the limits of spec-led ranking — which is the section no competitor in this category writes and the one we would most want you to read.

Two rules that apply to every ranking: every product card names who should not buy that product, including our top picks; and at least one pick in every roundup is one we advise against, with the reason. A roundup where everything is recommended is a catalog, not a ranking.

AI and how these pages are produced

Pages here are researched from primary sources — manufacturer specifications, listings and published papers — and the arithmetic is done and shown rather than asserted. Whatever tools are used in production, the standards on this page apply to the output: a claim without a source does not ship, and a figure without a provenance does not ship.

Conflicts of interest

We hold no equity in any manufacturer or retailer covered. We accept no free products, no loans and no review samples. No manufacturer has been given advance sight of a page, and none has been asked for one. If any of that ever changes, it will be disclosed on every affected page rather than in a footnote here.

Questions people actually ask

How do you decide what to recommend?
On published specifications, weighted by category, with the full criteria set out on the methodology page. We weight what a manufacturer actually publishes heavily — not as a proxy for quality, but because a checkable figure is something we can rank on and an adjective is not.
Do you correct mistakes?
Yes, and we date and describe the change rather than quietly amending. Corrections get read before anything else that comes through the contact form. If a spec has moved, a link has died, or a source does not say what we say it says, tell us.
Do manufacturers see pages before they publish?
No. None has been given advance sight of a page and none has been asked for one. We hold no equity in any manufacturer or retailer covered, and we accept no free products, loans or review samples.
Why do you not print prices?
We do not run a live price feed. A price typed once would be stale within days while being displayed as current, which is worse than no price. Every buy button goes to the live listing where the retailer's number is right at the moment you look.

Sources